Consumer Reports consistently ranks innerspring and hybrid mattresses from brands like Saatva, Tempur-Pedic, and WinkBeds near the top of its ratings, with back-support and motion-isolation scores driving the results.
Brand Ratings
Which mattress is best according to Consumer Reports?
Consumer Reports uses a standardized lab-testing method that scores mattresses on back support, edge support, motion isolation, and ease of movement. Ratings shift between annual test cycles as new models enter the lineup, so a brand that topped last year's list may not hold that position today. The publication doesn't sell mattresses, which keeps its rankings free from the pay-to-play placement that shapes most review sites.
- Consumer Reports tests mattresses across at least five performance categories, including back support and motion isolation.
- Saatva, Tempur-Pedic, and WinkBeds have each appeared near the top of Consumer Reports mattress rankings in recent test cycles.
- Consumer Reports subscribers access full scores and rankings behind a paywall; free visitors see only partial results.
- Consumer Reports rates both in-store and online-only mattress brands, covering foam, innerspring, and hybrid constructions.